I am a trained Osteopathic Physician and have
treated patients with and received osteopathic manipulation. Currently one of the most promising
therapies for food allergy, currently being researched in New York,
is a Chinese herbal therapy that blunts severe allergic reactions.
This has been successfully tested in mice and a human trial is
ongoing.
I believe that western medicine can be
intermingled with other non traditional therapies.
Unfortunately there are large number of therapies available that
have been shown to be not helpful or harmful. There are many
that we just have little data to support claims but have not shown
to be harmful.
In general if one test
or treatment will "cure" dozens of non related medical problems, it
is a fantasy. (example: high blood pressure- why do we have so
many different blood pressure pills? Yes, the drug companies make
money, but not the doctors who prescribe them. Speaking from
experience, if I had one pill that cured all high blood pressure, I
would prescribe it and so would 99.99% of all doctors. This
would make our lives easier and allow us to see more patients in a
day (how we make more money) and have to remember less facts.
The following tests and treatments offer little
promise, some therapies are dangerous and all have no scientific
support.
- IgG
antibody to any food: This test is
available and used by many Dr's. Specific IgG to food has
never been shown to have any clinical utility. If you have
this test done all results must be ignored. IgG is
normally produced by our immune system in response to the food
we ingest and it signifies tolerance.
- Tay SS,
Clark AT, Deighton J, King Y, Ewan
PW.Patterns of immunoglobulin G responses to egg and
peanut allergens are distinct: ovalbumin-specific
immunoglobulin responses are ubiquitous, but peanut-specific
immunoglobulin responses are up-regulated in peanut allergy.
Clin Exp Allergy. 2007 Oct;37(10):1512-8.
- Teuber SS, Beyer K.
IgG to foods: a test not ready for prime time.
Curr Opin Allergy Clin Immunol. 2007 Jun;7(3):257-8.
- Cytotoxicity testing: a food
allergen is added to a blood sample. Then the blood is examined
under a microscope to see if the white blood cells change shape
or disintegrate. There is no data to support this is diagnostic
of food allergy. This is expensive, your insurance does not
cover it, and the treatments prescribed are conveniently for
sale in the office.
- Provocative challenge: diluted food
allergen is either put under your tongue or injected under the
skin. Then you are to monitor your symptoms (i.e. arthritis)
and see if they worsen. Again there is no data that this
technique can diagnose food allergy.
- Immune complex assay: The blood is
evaluated for groups (complexes) of certain antibodies attached
to food antigen in the blood. This is a normal part of food
digestion and not a marker for food allergy.
- ELISA / ACT: testing: claim that
hidden allergies are the cause of over 60% of all human
illnesses. Blood is drawn and cultures of white blood cells
(lymphocytes) are observed to how they react to up to 300 foods,
minerals, preservatives and environmental substances. Of
course, the therapy again is some avoidances and supplements
sold by the person testing you.
- NAET: (Nambudripad's Allergy
Elimination Technique). The theory is that some foods can block
your energy fields, and inurn weaken your body. You hold the
suspect substance in your hand or even in close proximity to
your body. The practitioner pull down on your out stretched
arm. If you are deemed weaker then it is a positive. As the
test drags on more and more positives are found (in reality you
need more gym time. Kinisiologist perform this, some
chiropractors and acupuncturists perform a similar test
(acupuncture does work for a number of problems, I have received
treatments in the past, this is not one therapy you should try).
- Hair analysis: the mineral content
of your hair is analyzed. From this it is determined on whether
you have a mineral deficiency or a heavy metal poisoning that is
causing your food allergy.
- Multiple references but
many are
compiled in
Food Allergies For Dummies by
Rober A. Wood, MD
(click link)
Director of Pediatric Allergy and Immunology at Johns Hopkins.